Reflections on digital offline payments

Introduction

On 18/05 Bernhard Kauer (Founder & CEO by Puzzle2Pay) wrote an interesting blog on the need for digital offline payments, i.e. "Do we need digital offline payments?" - https://bkauer.medium.com/do-we-need-digital-offline-payments-3a74ec2d8c7b

Bernhard makes here an interesting argumentation that there is no real need for offline payments. After some reflection, I must admit I do not fully agree.

Below my argumentation in reply to his blog. Would love to hear your opinion.

1. More and more places are getting online

Definitely true, but internet connectivity is still an issue in certain emerging countries and even rural areas in developed countries.

Even if only a few percent are without connectivity, it's still worth to offer a solution for these places. Otherwise you exclude certain populations, but also the active users can come in very uncomfortable situations, when they are so used to a certain payment method and then realize it is not available (and don't have any alternative anymore).

Furthermore it's not because a place is online, that it's always the case, e.g.

Satellite internet might be too expensive for certain groups of people
Internet might not be available due to empty battery on your phone or due to data limits reached
Internet might be too expensive, due to high roaming costs. In Europe this is less of an issue, but if you go outside Europe roaming costs can still be exuberant.
In certain cases, you want to have an offline solution, as you don't want to have something requiring energy. E.g. a use case where you can find a price money in a forest (as a sort of treasury) might be a fun use case. Obviously you don't want to put a battery for multiple years, but it would be fun that you can scan a QR code and immediately claim the money.
Internet 4G/5G is still relatively unstable, due to telco network outages. Furthermore it becomes even more complex of airplanes or trains (even though solutions exist to have internet, they are typically quite difficult and expensive)

2. There is another approach to pay

Obviously correct, paying with trust is an option, but that's only the case when there is already some trust existing. Indeed in my regular bar there is no issue, but might be something different if I come in a place I have never been before.

3. It is getting easier

Agree that there are new means for establishing trust in a digital way, but most of the solutions you describe actually are also online solutions requiring your smartphone, which means it's not really a solution if my smartphone battery is down or I don't have internet.

4. Cash is the first contender for a long time

Fully agree, but isn't the whole point of those payment solutions for its users to be without cash? User experience is not great if you still need to carry cash as an alternative. Furthermore with cash becoming less and less common, ATMs will also become more and more rare, making the user experience for cash as alternative even worse.

So personally I would say that an offline solution is not a must-have, but it is a great nice-to-have or even should-have, as it drastically improves the user experience and the user's feeling of trust/confidence in the payment solutions (being able to pay always).

Furthermore you can envisage some offline payment solutions, which can perfectly complement an online solution. For example:

Obviously QR codes can reduce the need for online, but QR codes can support all 4 cases:

Scenario 1: Ideally both payer and recipient have internet connection. At that moment all checks can be done and both parties can be properly informed about the success/failure of the transaction.
Scenario 2: You can also support case of only payer having connectivity. At this moment payer scans QR code generated offline (containing merchant identifier & amount) by the merchant and confirms. All checks can be properly done, but merchant has to look on phone of payer to see if payment was successfully done (which opens a small door to fraud)
Scenario 3: Case of only merchant having connectivity. In this case payer generates a QR code containing his specific ID and authorization to pay specific merchant for specific amount. The merchant scans this QR code and debit operation can be done.
Scenario 4: Case of both not having internet. In this case setup of scenario 3 is most logical, which the merchant stores till he has connectivity. Obviously in this scenario, the merchant has no guarantee that payer has necessary funds at moment of paying.

Other options could be:

Charge a specific amount on a chip card, which can be read offline by specific PoS device
Charge specific amount on your smartphone, in the form of a digital key, which represents a specific owner and amount in encrypted way. User can pay with this via specific app at merchant side, by scanning QR code or even via NFC communication.
Usage of an electronic ID card (or identity app) to give a merchant a one-time Direct Debit consent to debit your account for agreed amount. Obviously in this case there is also no guarantee that merchant will get paid.

Comments

Transforming the insurance sector to an Open API Ecosystem

1. Introduction "Open" has recently become a new buzzword in the financial services industry, i.e. open data, open APIs, Open Banking, Open Insurance …, but what does this new buzzword really mean? "Open" refers to the capability of companies to expose their services to the outside world, so that external partners or even competitors can use these services to bring added value to their customers. This trend is made possible by the technological evolution of open APIs (Application Programming Interfaces), which are the digital ports making this communication possible. Together companies, interconnected through open APIs, form a true API ecosystem , offering best-of-breed customer experience, by combining the digital services offered by multiple companies. In the technology sector this evolution has been ongoing for multiple years (think about the travelling sector, allowing you to book any hotel online). An excelle...

RPA - The miracle solution for incumbent banks to bridge the automation gap with neo-banks?

Hypes and marketing buzz words are strongly present in the IT landscape. Often these are existing concepts, which have evolved technologically and are then renamed to a new term, as if it were a brand new technology or concept. If you want to understand and assess these new trends, it is important to reduce the concepts to their essence and compare them with existing technologies , e.g. Integration (middleware) software ensures that 2 separate applications or components can be integrated in an easy way. Of course, there is a huge evolution in the protocols, volumes of exchanged data, scalability, performance…, but in essence the problem remains the same. Nonetheless, there have been multiple terms for integration software such as ETL, ESB, EAI, SOA, Service Mesh… Data storage software ensures that data is stored in such a way that data is not lost and that there is some kind guaranteed consistency, maximum availability and scalability, easy retrieval...

IoT - Revolution or Evolution in the Financial Services Industry

1. The IoT hype We have all heard about the "Internet of Things" (IoT) as this revolutionary new technology, which will radically change our lives. But is it really such a revolution and will it really have an impact on the Financial Services Industry? To refresh our memory, the Internet of Things (IoT) refers to any object , which is able to collect data and communicate and share this information (like condition, geolocation…) over the internet . This communication will often occur between 2 objects (i.e. not involving any human), which is often referred to as Machine-to-Machine (M2M) communication. Well known examples are home thermostats, home security systems, fitness and health monitors, wearables… This all seems futuristic, but smartphones, tablets and smartwatches can also be considered as IoT devices. More importantly, beside these futuristic visions of IoT, the smartphone will most likely continue to be the cent...

Are product silos in a bank inevitable?

Silo thinking is often frowned upon in the industry. It is often a synonym for bureaucratic processes and politics and in almost every article describing the threats of new innovative Fintech players on the banking industry, the strong bank product silos are put forward as one of the main blockages why incumbent banks are not able to (quickly) react to the changing customer expectations. Customers want solutions to their problems and do not want to be bothered about the internal organisation of their bank. Most banks are however organized by product domain (daily banking, investments and lending) and by customer segmentation (retail banking, private banking, SMEs and corporates). This division is reflected both at business and IT side and almost automatically leads to the creation of silos. It is however difficult to reorganize a bank without creating new silos or introducing other types of issues and inefficiencies. An organization is never ideal and needs to take a numbe...

PSD3: The Next Phase in Europe’s Payment Services Regulation

With the successful rollout of PSD2, the European Union (EU) continues to advance innovation in the payments domain through the anticipated introduction of the Payment Services Directive 3 (PSD3) . On June 28, 2023, the European Commission published a draft proposal for PSD3 and the Payment Services Regulation (PSR) . The finalized versions of this directive and associated regulation are expected to be available by late 2024, although some predictions suggest a more likely timeline of Q2 or Q3 2025. Given that member states are typically granted an 18-month transition period, PSD3 is expected to come into effect sometime in 2026. Notably, the Commission has introduced a regulation (PSR) alongside the PSD3 directive, ensuring more harmonization across member states as regulations are immediately effective and do not require national implementation, unlike directives. PSD3 shares the same objectives as PSD2, i.e. increasing competition in the payments landscape and en...

Trade-offs Are Inevitable in Software Delivery - Remember the CAP Theorem

In the world of financial services, the integrity of data systems is fundamentally reliant on non-functional requirements (NFRs) such as reliability and security. Despite their importance, NFRs often receive secondary consideration during project scoping, typically being reduced to a generic checklist aimed more at compliance than at genuine functionality. Regrettably, these initial NFRs are seldom met after delivery, which does not usually prevent deployment to production due to the vague and unrealistic nature of the original specifications. This common scenario results in significant end-user frustration as the system does not perform as expected, often being less stable or slower than anticipated. This situation underscores the need for better education on how to articulate and define NFRs , i.e. demanding only what is truly necessary and feasible within the given budget. Early and transparent discussions can lead to system architecture being tailored more close...

Low- and No-code platforms - Will IT developers soon be out of a job?

“ The future of coding is no coding at all ” - Chris Wanstrath (CEO at GitHub). Mid May I posted a blog on RPA (Robotic Process Automation - https://bankloch.blogspot.com/2020/05/rpa-miracle-solution-for-incumbent.html ) on how this technology, promises the world to companies. A very similar story is found with low- and no-code platforms, which also promise that business people, with limited to no knowledge of IT, can create complex business applications. These platforms originate , just as RPA tools, from the growing demand for IT developments , while IT cannot keep up with the available capacity. As a result, an enormous gap between IT teams and business demands is created, which is often filled by shadow-IT departments, which extend the IT workforce and create business tools in Excel, Access, WordPress… Unfortunately these tools built in shadow-IT departments arrive very soon at their limits, as they don’t support the required non-functional requirements (like h...

An overview of 1-year blogging

Last week I published my 60th post on my blog called Bankloch (a reference to "Banking" and my family name). The past year, I have published a blog on a weekly basis, providing my humble personal vision on the topics of Fintech, IT software delivery and mobility. This blogging has mainly been a personal enrichment , as it forced me to dive deep into a number of different topics, not only in researching for content, but also in trying to identify trends, innovations and patterns into these topics. Furthermore it allowed me to have several very interesting conversations and discussions with passionate colleagues in the financial industry and to get more insights into the wonderful world of blogging and more general of digital marketing, exploring subjects and tools like: Search Engine Optimization (SEO) LinkedIn post optimization Google Search Console Google AdWorks Google Blogger Thinker360 Finextra … Clearly it is not easy to get the necessary ...

The UPI Phenomenon: From Zero to 10 Billion

If there is one Indian innovation that has grabbed global headlines , it is undoubtedly the instant payment system UPI (Unified Payments Interface) . In August 2023, monthly UPI transactions exceeded an astounding 10 billion, marking a remarkable milestone for India’s payments ecosystem. No wonder that UPI has not only revolutionized transactions in India but has also gained international recognition for its remarkable growth. Launched in 2016 by the National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) in collaboration with 21 member banks, UPI quickly became popular among consumers and businesses. In just a few years, it achieved remarkable milestones : By August 2023, UPI recorded an unprecedented 10.58 billion transactions , with an impressive 50% year-on-year growth. This volume represented approximately 190 billion euros . In July 2023, the UPI network connected 473 different banks . UPI is projected to achieve a staggering 1 ...

AI in Financial Services - A buzzword that is here to stay!

In a few of my most recent blogs I tried to demystify some of the buzzwords (like blockchain, Low- and No-Code platforms, RPA…), which are commonly used in the financial services industry. These buzzwords often entail interesting innovations, but contrary to their promise, they are not silver bullets solving any problem. Another such buzzword is AI (or also referred to as Machine Learning, Deep Learning, Enforced Learning… - the difference between those terms put aside). Again this term is also seriously hyped, creating unrealistic expectations, but contrary to many other buzzwords, this is something I truly believe will have a much larger impact on the financial services industry than many other buzzwords. This opinion is backed by a study of McKinsey and PWC indicating that 72% of company leaders consider that AI will be the most competitive advantage of the future and that this technology will be the most disruptive force in the decades to come. Deep Lea...

Bankloch

Search This Blog